Shopify vs BigCommerce: which ecommerce platform is better?

A practical comparison of Shopify and BigCommerce covering costs, built-in features, apps, B2B, SEO, scalability and day-to-day ease of use.

By the UK Technology Hub teamPublished 4 minute read

The short answer

Shopify is easier to use, has the largest app and theme ecosystem and suits most direct-to-consumer brands. BigCommerce includes more features out of the box, doesn't charge extra transaction fees for using third-party payment providers and is strong for larger catalogs and B2B selling. Both handle SEO, scale and headless setups well. The best choice depends on your catalog, sales model and team.

Shopify and BigCommerce are the two biggest hosted ecommerce platforms in the US. Both are reliable, secure and capable of running serious businesses. They differ in philosophy: Shopify keeps the core simple and relies on apps, while BigCommerce builds more features into the platform itself.

Quick comparison

ShopifyBigCommerce
Ease of useVery easyEasy, with more settings to learn
Built-in featuresCore features, extended with appsMore features included natively
App and theme ecosystemLargest in ecommerceSmaller but solid
Payment flexibilityExtra fee if you don't use Shopify PaymentsNo extra platform fee for third-party gateways
B2BStrong on higher plansStrong, with dedicated B2B tooling
Large catalogs and complex variantsGoodVery good
HeadlessHydrogen, Storefront APIStrong APIs and headless integrations

Pricing, features and plan limits change, so check both platforms' current pricing pages before deciding.

Ease of use

Shopify's admin is famously simple. New store owners can add products, manage orders and install apps with little training. BigCommerce's admin offers more options in the core platform, which is powerful but can feel busier at first.

Features versus apps

On Shopify, many features come from apps: product filters, subscriptions, wholesale pricing, advanced reviews and more. Apps make Shopify flexible, but monthly app fees and extra scripts add up, which can affect cost and speed.

BigCommerce includes more natively, such as product options, customer groups and certain B2B features, so you may need fewer apps.

Costs

Both charge monthly plans. Key differences:

  • Transaction fees: Shopify adds a fee if you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments. BigCommerce doesn't charge extra platform fees for third-party gateways.
  • Sales-based plan limits: BigCommerce plans have annual online sales thresholds that can move you to a higher plan as you grow.
  • Apps: Shopify stores often pay more in app subscriptions.

Model your expected sales and needed apps over two or three years on both platforms.

B2B and wholesale

Both platforms now support B2B selling, including customer-specific pricing, net payment terms, quotes and purchase orders, though the most advanced B2B tools sit on higher-tier plans. BigCommerce has long been popular for B2B and complex catalogs. Our guide to B2B ecommerce explains what to look for.

SEO

Both handle the basics: editable titles and descriptions, sitemaps, SSL and structured data. Shopify's fixed URL prefixes (/products/, /collections/) are a common complaint; BigCommerce offers more URL flexibility. In practice, content, speed and links matter more than these differences.

Scalability and performance

Both platforms handle high traffic and large sales volumes. Shopify Plus and BigCommerce Enterprise serve large brands. Performance depends heavily on theme quality and the number of apps and scripts.

Headless commerce

If you want a fully custom front end, both offer strong APIs. Shopify has its Hydrogen framework and Oxygen hosting; BigCommerce integrates with popular frameworks and content systems. Our headless commerce guide explains when that approach makes sense.

Which should you choose?

Choose Shopify if:

  • You're a direct-to-consumer brand that values ease of use.
  • You want the widest choice of themes, apps and experienced developers.
  • You plan to use Shopify Payments.

Choose BigCommerce if:

  • You have a large or complex catalog.
  • You want more built-in features and fewer app subscriptions.
  • You need flexibility with payment providers.
  • B2B selling is a big part of your business.

Questions to settle before choosing

  1. How many products and variants will you have in three years?
  2. Which payment provider do you want to use, and why?
  3. Which apps or integrations are must-haves, and do they support both platforms?
  4. Will wholesale or B2B sales become important?
  5. Who on your team will run the store day to day?

Write your answers down and ask each platform's sales team, or an independent partner, to respond to them. The right answer usually becomes clear quickly.

Migrating between them

Moving from one to the other is common. Products, customers and orders can be migrated with tools, but themes are rebuilt, and redirects are essential to protect search rankings.

How we help

Our e-commerce team helps US businesses choose, build and migrate stores. Our Shopify development service handles Shopify builds and migrations, and our web app team builds custom integrations and headless front ends on either platform.

Frequently asked questions

Is BigCommerce cheaper than Shopify?

It depends on your sales, payment provider and app needs. BigCommerce can be cheaper if you'd otherwise pay Shopify's extra transaction fees or many app subscriptions.

Which is better for SEO, Shopify or BigCommerce?

Both are good. BigCommerce offers more URL flexibility, but content, speed and links matter far more.

Can I move from BigCommerce to Shopify?

Yes. Data can be migrated with tools, the design is usually rebuilt, and 301 redirects protect your search rankings.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and details such as prices, features and rules can change. Product and company names mentioned are trademarks of their respective owners and are used only to identify those products; UK Technology Hub is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

Related guides

B2B ecommerce: how to sell wholesale online

How to move wholesale and trade sales online, the features B2B buyers expect, platform options and how to roll it out without upsetting existing accounts.

All e-commerce & Shopify guides for US businesses