How to test and evaluate AI features before you launch

A practical approach to testing AI features: building test sets, measuring accuracy and safety, using automated checks and monitoring quality after launch.

By the UK Technology Hub teamPublished 4 minute read

The short answer

AI features need testing just like any other software, but because outputs vary, you test against a collection of realistic examples rather than single cases. Build an evaluation set of real inputs with expected outcomes, define clear quality measures, grade results with automated checks and human review, test for safety and misuse, rerun tests whenever prompts or models change, and monitor live quality.

Traditional software either works or it doesn't: the same input gives the same output. AI features are different. The same question can produce slightly different answers, and a small change to a prompt or model can improve some cases while breaking others. That's why AI needs its own testing discipline, often called evaluation, or "evals."

Step 1: Define what good looks like

Before testing, agree on success criteria. Examples:

  • A support assistant answers correctly from approved content in at least 90% of common questions.
  • It never promises refunds or discounts.
  • It hands over to a person when unsure.
  • An invoice extractor captures totals correctly in 98% of documents.
  • A summariser includes every action item from a meeting.

Clear criteria turn "it seems fine" into something measurable.

Step 2: Build an evaluation set

Collect realistic examples:

  • Common cases from real data: frequent questions, typical documents.
  • Edge cases: typos, incomplete information, unusual formats.
  • Out-of-scope requests: things the AI should refuse or redirect.
  • Adversarial inputs: attempts to trick it, extract hidden instructions or produce harmful content.
  • Sensitive scenarios: complaints, distressed users, legal questions.

For each example, record the expected outcome or the qualities a good answer must have. Start with 50 to 100 examples and grow over time.

Step 3: Choose how to grade

Exact or rule-based checks. For structured outputs: is the extracted date correct? Is the JSON valid? Did the answer include a link to the source?

Reference comparisons. Compare the output with a model answer for key facts.

Model-graded evaluation. Use a separate AI model with a clear rubric to grade answers for accuracy, relevance or tone. This scales well, but check its judgements against human grading periodically.

Human review. Essential for nuanced quality, tone and high-risk content. Use clear scoring guidelines so reviewers are consistent.

Step 4: Test safety and misuse

  • Can users override instructions through prompt injection?
  • Does the AI reveal confidential instructions or data?
  • Does it handle harmful, abusive or off-topic requests appropriately?
  • Does it avoid giving professional advice it shouldn't?
  • Does it respect permissions, only accessing data the user is allowed to see?

Deliberately trying to break your own system, sometimes called red-teaming, finds problems before users do.

Step 5: Test grounding and hallucinations

For features that answer from your documents, check that each claim is supported by the retrieved content. Our guide to AI hallucinations explains techniques for reducing invented answers.

Step 6: Regression testing

Rerun your evaluation set every time you change:

  • Prompts. Our prompt engineering guide covers managing prompts like code.
  • Models or model versions.
  • Retrieval settings or source content.
  • Tools and integrations.

Compare scores with the previous version before releasing. A change that improves the average can still break important cases.

Step 7: Measure performance and cost

Alongside quality, track response time and cost per request. A slightly less accurate model that's much faster and cheaper may be the right choice for some tasks.

Step 8: Monitor after launch

  • Log inputs and outputs, with privacy safeguards.
  • Collect user feedback such as thumbs up or down.
  • Sample conversations for human review.
  • Track escalation rates and error reports.
  • Add new failure cases to your evaluation set.

Quality can drift as user behaviour, content and models change.

Tools

Many evaluation tools and frameworks exist, from simple spreadsheets and scripts to dedicated platforms that run test sets, compare versions and track results. Start simple: a spreadsheet of examples and a script that runs them is far better than no testing.

Who should own AI quality?

Assign a clear owner for each AI feature: someone who maintains the evaluation set, reviews results and signs off changes. Involve subject experts from the business, such as support leads or product specialists, in defining what a good answer looks like. Quality isn't just an engineering task.

Common mistakes

  • Testing only with a handful of easy examples.
  • Changing prompts in production without rerunning tests.
  • Relying entirely on AI grading without human checks.
  • Ignoring cost and speed.
  • Not testing misuse.

How we help

Our AI solutions team builds evaluation sets and testing pipelines for AI features. Our AI chatbot projects include pre-launch testing and monitoring dashboards, and our web app developers integrate evaluation into your release process.

Frequently asked questions

How many test cases do I need for an AI feature?

Start with 50 to 100 realistic examples covering common, edge and misuse cases, and keep adding as you learn.

Can AI grade AI outputs?

Yes, with clear rubrics, and it scales well. Check its grading against human reviewers regularly.

How often should I rerun AI tests?

Whenever prompts, models, content or integrations change, and periodically to catch drift.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and details such as prices, features and rules can change. Product and company names mentioned are trademarks of their respective owners and are used only to identify those products; UK Technology Hub is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

Related guides

All AI & automation guides